Tag: Covers

Categories
Tunes

100 best covers: #38 Teenage Fanclub “Mr. Tambourine man”

<< #39    |    #37 >>

Scottish alt rock legends, Teenage Fanclub have appeared many times over on these pages since this blog’s inception. In fact, they’ve already graced this particular list once with their cover of a great track by another iconic Scottish alt-rock band and – spoiler alert – you’ll likely see them again on this list before it reaches its end.

I first heard this particular cover of “Mr. Tambourine Man” when a friend of mine put it on a mixed tape for me. I later learned of its provenance when I found a used copy of the 3-CD compilation “Ruby trax” at Penguin Music in the late 90s, a compilation that has also received due mention in relation to this list of great covers. I remember thinking it quite apt that the Fannies chose to cover this particular track given that I had found that the jangling guitar and harmonizing vocals on their 1993 album “Thirteen” harkened back to the folk rock sound practically invented by The Byrds. Of course, this was before I learned that Teenage Fanclub was just as enamoured of Big Star and that The Byrds’ “Mr. Tambourine Man” was itself a cover of a Bob Dylan track*.

The Teenage Fanclub cover has way more in common with The Byrds version than with Bob Dylan’s original. Indeed, it’s almost an exact replica of The Byrds’ rendition, only a slightly bit shorter and perhaps a bit more raw in the vocals. The Byrds released their cover in spring 1965, less than a month after Dylan released his original. Both of these versions were very successful for those artists, topping charts and inspiring generations of musicians. The Byrds cut a few verses from Dylan’s composition, changed the time signature, and the recording is half the length. It’s 12 string jangle rock versus pure balladeering folk.

You can definitely tell that Teenage Fanclub owed more a debt to The Byrds than to Bob Dylan with their faithful ode. Some might knock them for it, but not me. And though the two covers are quite different from the original I love them all and refuse to go with one over the others.

Cover:

Original:

*Having only had limited exposure to both Dylan and The Byrds via my parents’ oldies radio station listening, I would later go on to learn that The Byrds covered many Bob Dylan tunes while exploring both of their catalogues much, much later.

For the rest of the 100 best covers list, click here.

Categories
Tunes

100 best covers: #39 Great Big Sea “Run runaway”

<< #40    |    #38 >>

Great Big Sea has long since been a household name here in Canada and is relatively well-known elsewhere as well, counting amongst their fans actor Russell Crowe. They are likely the most famous band to come out of Newfoundland and for a while during the late 90s and into the 2000s, were one of the best-selling groups here, their high-energy folk and updated interpretations of traditional sea shanties obviously finding a home in the hearts of good Canadian youth.

It certainly found me on first listen with this very cover of Slade’s* “Run runaway”. I remember catching the video at some point in the summer of 1995 or 1996 on MuchMusic, right around the time their video for “Mari Mac” also caught my attention. It wasn’t long at all before these two songs could be heard from open residence room doors and through the open windows of student apartments all around Toronto. Both are excellent tunes but it was this re-interpretation that first sold me.

Slade’s original came out around the time that I was just finding my own feet with music, branching out from my parents’ oldies radio listening in the car and regularly watching the chumFM top 30 countdown on CityTV. I didn’t, of course, know this at the time, but this was Slade’s second go round and comeback venture, their biggest inroads into the North American market. They had been flirting with glam rock throughout the 70s and were quite popular at home in England. It took a cover by metal band Quiet Riot of their 70s hit “Cum on feel the noize” to finally drum up interest in the US, leading to a signing with a US label, and the first single released was, of course, “Run runaway”.

Recorded for their 11th studio album, “The amazing kamikaze syndrome”, “Run runaway” was very much of its time. It has soaring guitars that put together a stadium-ready hook and there’s those shout-along vocals that had me along for the ride, even though I didn’t understand them. But it was far from a sellout. Slade didn’t stray far from their roots, employing electric violin and adapting traditional Scottish jig elements for a hard rock world.

Then, more than a decade later, Great Big Sea, removed the rock and upped the traditional. Their cover has flutes, accordions and fiddles and is sung like a shanty. They even made it more upbeat, which I wouldn’t have thought possible as a pre-teen.

And though the original has the nostalgia factor going for it, I gotta give the edge to the cover here.

Cover:

Original:

*This is, I believe, the second cover of a Slade tune to find its way on to this list.

For the rest of the 100 best covers list, click here.

Categories
Tunes

100 best covers: #40 Iron And Wine “Such great heights”

<< #41    |    #39 >>

Back in May, I travelled down to Toronto to see a concert for which I had purchased tickets almost six months beforehand. The show in question was certainly worth all the pre-planning and the additional travel: one of the few stops on the tour by Death Cab for Cutie and The Postal Service celebrating the 20th (er… 21st) anniversary of these bands’ landmark 2003 albums, “Transatlanticism” and “Give up”. It was double duty for Ben Gibbard, frontman of both acts, as he performed two sets on the evening, both feted albums from beginning to end, before coming back to perform a two-song encore, the first song* of which was “Such great heights” (again), which Gibbard introduced as a cover of an Iron And Wine song.

Gibbard was joking, of course, but there was a kernel of truth in there somewhere as well.

When “Such great heights” was launched as the first single from “Give up”, it was released as a four song EP, including covers of two of the album’s songs by two of The Postal Service’s Sub Pop label mates**. The Iron And Wine cover was very nearly as popular as the original, both versions coming to the public’s consciousness at around the same time, and the fact that the pair were very different in sound and style but equally catchy probably helped record sales for both artists. The cover was featured on the “Garden State” soundtrack, a massive vehicle for certain indie artists at that time, and the two versions appeared in multiple TV advertising campaigns.

The Postal Service’s original is a digital beast. The upbeat chiming synths and frenetic rhythm reflect the almost blinding optimism and exuberant subject matter of love and hope, a rarity in Gibbard’s early songwriting. Played back to back, the Iron And Wine cover is still nearly unrecognizable as the same composition. It has a tempo slowed down a hundred million times and is austere in its acoustic guitar finger picking and Sam Beam’s soft and wistful delivery. The production, too, is like a 180, sounding ancient, rather than futuristic, analog versus digital. You can almost hear imagined vinyl crackling overlaying the audible breaths between lines and the tactile feel of the calloused fingertips on the strings.

Both versions are swoon worthy, each a work of beauty in their own right. I couldn’t possibly choose one over the other, unless the mood dictated a certain aesthetic on a given day. Of course, it would be the opposite on the next.

I call this one a draw.

Cover:

Original:

*The second one being an actual cover of Depeche Mode’s “Enjoy the silence”!

**The other was The Shins’ cover of “We will become silhouettes”.

For the rest of the 100 best covers list, click here.